Back to News

When the Fields go Quiet: Navigating Grief in Rural Life

Reference: National Farmer Mental Health Alliance

Trigger warning: This article discusses grief, animal loss, financial stress, isolation, mental health challenges, and suicide risk in rural and agricultural communities. Please take care of yourself as you read and feel free to pause or step away whenever you need to.

For those who live and work in agriculture, grief can involve family and friends, animals, land, livelihood, financial security, family traditions, independence, and identity. These losses may happen suddenly or develop slowly, leaving people grieving long before a loss actually occurs. Farming, ranching, and rodeo are often deeply connected to family history, personal values, community, and purpose.

There are different types of grief. Understanding its different forms can help us recognize losses that might otherwise go unnamed (Hamilton, 2016).

  • Anticipatory grief: Grieving a loss before it happens, such as facing a disease outbreak that threatens a herd or recognizing that a family operation may not be financially sustainable.
  • Disenfranchised grief: Grief that is not fully recognized or supported by others. Losing a working dog or livestock herd may be dismissed as “just business,” despite the emotional, financial, and generational significance of the loss.
  • Cumulative grief: Multiple losses occurring over time without enough opportunity to recover, such as financial pressures, animal deaths, family conflict, and health concerns.
  • Traumatic grief: Grief following sudden or distressing experiences, including unexpected animal deaths, serious injuries, or disease outbreaks. This can be generational as well.
  • Prolonged or complicated grief: Grief that remains intense and significantly interferes with daily functioning.
  • Identity-based grief: Mourning a part of ourselves or a future we expected, such as when illness, injury, or financial circumstances mean we can no longer farm or do the livelihood we planned on.

It’s also important to note that these experiences and grief types can overlap (Bonanno & Kaltman, 2001). Losing a working dog, for example, may mean losing a beloved companion, an essential part of daily operations, and a source of independence. If a bull rider is injured and cannot ride, they may be experiencing traumatic and identity-based grief at the same time. The expectation to keep going can make it difficult to acknowledge when emotional support is needed.

We might tell ourselves:
  • “I’ll deal with this when things slow down.”
  • “Other people have it worse.”
  • “I should be able to handle this myself.”
What can grief look like? That might sound like a silly question, but grief does not always look like crying. It can show up as numbness, irritability, exhaustion, sleep difficulties, or feeling disconnected from others. Continuing to work does not mean someone is unaffected by loss, and acknowledging grief is not a sign of weakness.

It sounds wild, but sometimes we just need to recognize that what we are experiencing is grief. This can happen months or years after (or before) an event (anticipatory grief). Disenfranchised grief can make us feel extremely isolated. Grief and stress can also impact our mental abilities, such as memory, making us doubt ourselves and feel like strangers in our own mind (Farmer & Matlin, 2018).

Read more